×
Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
Search
Search
Court's assisted-suicide ruling raises prospect of 'kill at will'Court's assisted-suicide ruling raises prospect of 'kill at will'

Court's assisted-suicide ruling raises prospect of 'kill at will'

The idea has quickly taken hold that the Supreme Court of Canada struck down a law prohibiting doctors from assisting at suicides. It did not, says Peter Stockland

Peter Stockland
By Peter Stockland
1 minute read
The belief has grown since last Friday’s Supreme Court of Canada decision that we will have legalized doctor-assisted suicide by next year.
 
It’s a terribly mistaken assumption. We might have doctor-assisted suicide. We might just as easily have doctor, lawyer and local Hell’s Angel chieftain assisted suicide.
 
We might have an entirely lawless Canada as far as assisted suicide is concerned, what Calgary lawyer Gerry Chipeur refers to as “no country for old men.” Or middle-aged women. Or possibly even young children.
 
The misunderstanding of what might come arises from confusion over what the Supreme Court of Canada really decided. The idea has quickly taken hold that it struck down a law prohibiting doctors from assisting at suicides. It did not. It invalidated a law that prevents “everyone” — everyone — from assisting another person to commit suicide. The law also forbids anyone — anyone — from asking another person for help to commit suicide.
 
There is nothing in Section 241 of the federal Criminal Code about doctors.
 
Continue reading this article at the Calgary Herald website.

You'll also enjoy...

New Justice, New Challenges?

New Justice, New Challenges?

Yet when the courts strike down all manner of legislation from recent laws setting minimum sentences to prostitution provisions that date back more than a century, when they set aside the appointment of a Conservative judicial appointment, Robert Nadon, when they rule against all government proposal...

Divesting Diversity of Meaning

Divesting Diversity of Meaning

Canadians have developed a swelling pride about creating a country where respect for difference is key to the national spirit. But in this deep dive into what we mean by diversity, Ottawa writer Don Hutchinson says recent developments risk draining the concept of any common understanding.

'There's also another line of authority in Canada'

'There's also another line of authority in Canada'

(The Cardus Daily's Peter Stockland spoke to Toronto lawyer Phil Horgan, national president of the Catholic Civil Rights League, about two events last week that brought freedom of speech to the forefront of public debate Cardus: The Supreme Court's decision last week in the William Whatcott case is ...